Aaron Judge Rookie Card Value Guide

2017 Topps Series 1 #287

By Bob Villemure • Updated September 3, 2025

# Aaron Judge Rookie Card Value (Updated August 2025) The sports card market continues to evolve, and Aaron Judge's rookie cards remain a fascinating aspect for both collectors and investors. The New York Yankees' powerhouse has not only thrilled fans with his incredible on-field performances but has also driven significant interest in his rookie cards. In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore recent market trends, pricing, scarcity, and offer insights into the best investments for Aaron Judge rookie cards in 2025.

Quick-Stats Panel

-

Market Insights:

Over the last 30-90 days, Aaron Judge's rookie cards have seen a moderate increase in demand, with sales comps from platforms like eBay and sportscardinvestor.com showing consistent activity. -

Player Stats:

As of August 2025, Judge has hit 35 home runs and logged an impressive .290 batting average, reinforcing his status as an elite player. -

Market Sentiment:

Overall sentiment remains positive, driven by Judge's leadership in the Yankees' playoff push.

Price Table

Here's a breakdown of the 30-day average sale prices for Aaron Judge's Topps Chrome Rookie Card #169 across PSA and SGC grades:

Grade	PSA	SGC
10	$750	$700
9	$300	$275
8	$150	$130
7	$80	$75
1	$20	$15

12-Month Trend Summary

Over the past year, the price of Aaron Judge's rookie cards has experienced notable fluctuations: -

Peak:

Prices peaked in April 2025, coinciding with Judge's historic home run streak. -

Dip:

A slight dip occurred in June due to mid-season fatigue and a minor injury. -

Current Trajectory:

Prices have stabilized and are on a slow upward trend as the Yankees eye postseason success.

Most Valuable Cards & Key Investments

2017 Bowman Chrome Rookie Auto:

This card is highly sought after due to its on-card autograph and early release during Judge's rookie season. It's a staple for serious collectors.

2017 Topps Heritage Real One Auto:

Known for its retro design, this card is cherished for its aesthetics and scarcity.

2017 Topps Update US99:

Popular among collectors for its availability and historical significance, this card is a solid investment for those looking to enter the market.

Population Report + Scarcity Commentary

According to PSA.com, the estimated population of Topps Chrome Rookie Cards (PSA graded) is approximately: -

PSA 10:

2,300 cards -

PSA 9:

4,500 cards For SGC, the numbers are slightly lower, with less than 1,000 graded 10s. The scarcity of high-grade cards contributes to their premium pricing. This limited supply, combined with growing demand, keeps the cards' market vibrant.

Upcoming Competition

As the Yankees gear up for their next series against the Houston Astros, Judge will face formidable pitching from the likes of Justin Verlander. Historically, Judge has performed well against the Astros, but attention to his ability to adapt to high-caliber pitching will be crucial.

Best Cards to Buy Now

Buy/Sell/Hold Outlook:

Given Judge's current form and the Yankees' playoff potential, investing in his rookie cards appears promising. -

Buy:

Topps Chrome PSA 10, especially if you anticipate Judge's continued excellence. -

Hold:

Bowman Chrome Rookie Auto, which can appreciate further if Judge maintains his all-star performances. -

Sell:

Lower-grade cards if you need immediate liquidity or expect increased market volatility.

Collector's Recommendation:

Given Aaron Judge's status and fan following, diversifying across his most valuable cards, especially in higher grades, can be a prudent strategy.

User Questions in JSON

Investing in Aaron Judge's rookie cards can be a rewarding experience, blending passion for the sport with the potential for financial gain. As the market evolves, staying informed and strategic in your investments will ensure success.

FAQs

How accurate are these values?

These estimates are based on recent sales data from platforms like eBay and sportscardinvestor.com, reflecting current market trends.

What are the best brands to invest in for long-term value?

Bowman Chrome 1st autos, Topps Chrome RCs, and Panini Prizm are popular for rookies.

How do I know if my card is worth grading?

Check for centering, corners, edges, and surface quality to determine if grading will enhance its value.

What does PSA 10 mean?

PSA 10 is Gem Mint—virtually perfect, with no visible flaws.

Is it a good time to buy Aaron Judge rookie cards?

Yes, especially with his strong performance and the Yankees' playoff potential.

Methodology & Ethics

Data sources — Goldin Auctions closing prices, eBay Terapeak analytics, and PSA Auction Prices Realized.

Sampling window — We analyse the latest 90 days of public sales. A grade appears in our tables only when at least three verified transactions exist for that grade.

AI-grading disclaimer — MarketSnap’s grade suggestions are algorithmic and should be verified by a professional grader before you buy, sell, or submit a card.

Affiliate transparency — When you click a link to an external marketplace we may earn a referral commission at no extra cost to you. These partnerships never influence a card’s ranking or our editorial commentary.

Copyright © 2018–2025 MarketSnap. All rights reserved.

📈 Generate instant AI grade & comps