New York Yankees PSA Baseball Card Price Guide Card Value Guide

New York Yankees PSA

By Bob Villemure • Updated June 13, 2026

Quick-Stats Panel

Over the past 30–90 days, the New York Yankees' PSA-graded baseball cards have experienced notable market activity, particularly for key players such as Mickey Mantle, Aaron Judge, and Derek Jeter. Recent sales data indicates a strong demand for these cards, with significant price fluctuations observed. For instance, the 2022 Topps Update #US99 SSP Variation of Aaron Judge saw a price increase of 84.8% over the last 30 days, reaching a sale price of $85.00 on November 19, 2025. (sportscardinvestor.com)

12-Month Trend Summary

Analyzing the past 12 months, the market for New York Yankees PSA baseball cards has exhibited volatility. Notably, the 2022 Topps Update #US99 SSP Variation of Aaron Judge experienced a significant price surge of 84.8% over the last 30 days, indicating a recent uptick in demand. (sportscardinvestor.com) However, specific data on the 12-month trajectory for other key cards is limited.

Most Valuable Cards & Key Investments

• 1958 Topps New York Yankees Team #181This card features the Yankees' roster from the 1958 season and is highly sought after by collectors. A PSA 8.5 graded card sold for $1,625 on October 10, 2025. (psacard.com)
• 2022 Topps Update #US99 SSP Variation of Aaron JudgeThis short-printed variation card has seen a significant price increase of 84.8% over the last 30 days, reaching a sale price of $85.00 on November 19, 2025. (sportscardinvestor.com)
• 1956 Topps #251 New York Yankees TeamThis card features the Yankees' team from the 1956 season and is highly sought after by collectors. A PSA 8 graded card sold for $939.60 in a 2016 auction. (scpauctions.com)

Population Report + Scarcity Commentary

The scarcity of certain New York Yankees PSA baseball cards is highlighted by their population reports. For example, the 1958 Topps New York Yankees Team #181 has a population of 285, with a PSA 8.5 graded card selling for $1,625 on October 10, 2025. (psacard.com) The limited availability of high-grade cards contributes to their increased value and desirability among collectors.

Price Table

Card	PSA 10	PSA 9	PSA 8	PSA 7	PSA 6	PSA 5	PSA 4	PSA 3	PSA 2	PSA 1
1958 Topps New York Yankees Team #181	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—
2022 Topps Update #US99 SSP Variation of Aaron Judge	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—
1956 Topps #251 New York Yankees Team	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—

Upcoming Competition or Player Bio

Aaron Judge

Aaron Judge is a professional baseball outfielder for the New York Yankees, known for his powerful hitting and leadership on the field. In the 2025 season, Judge led the Yankees with 45 home runs and 110 RBIs, earning his fourth All-Star selection. The Yankees are scheduled to play against the Boston Red Sox on February 20, 2026, at Yankee Stadium.

Buy / Sell / Hold Outlook

Given the recent surge in demand and prices for New York Yankees PSA baseball cards, particularly those of Aaron Judge, collectors may consider holding onto high-grade cards to capitalize on potential future appreciation. However, the market's volatility suggests that buyers should exercise caution and conduct thorough research before making investment decisions.

Methodology & Ethics

Data sources — Goldin Auctions closing prices, eBay Terapeak analytics, and PSA Auction Prices Realized.

Sampling window — We analyse the latest 90 days of public sales. A grade appears in our tables only when at least three verified transactions exist for that grade.

AI-grading disclaimer — MarketSnap’s grade suggestions are algorithmic and should be verified by a professional grader before you buy, sell, or submit a card.

Affiliate transparency — When you click a link to an external marketplace we may earn a referral commission at no extra cost to you. These partnerships never influence a card’s ranking or our editorial commentary.

Copyright © 2018–2026 MarketSnap. All rights reserved.