Willie Mays 1958 Topps Card Value Guide
5
Quick-Stats Panel
The 1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays card has seen varied market activity over the past 30–90 days. Notable sales include:
- PSA 5 GradeSold for $242.00 on November 15, 2025. (ebay.com)
- PSA 5 GradeSold for $499.00 on December 10, 2025. (ebay.com)
- PSA 4 GradeSold for $544.50 on December 20, 2025. (ebay.com)
- SGC 3 GradeSold for $184.79 on October 5, 2025. (ebay.com)
- PSA 4 GradeSold for $197.99 on September 15, 2025. (ebay.com)
- PSA 1 GradeSold for $149.96 on December 1, 2023. (ebay.com)
-
1958 Topps - Willie Mays #5 POOR
$39.99 · Buy It Now -
1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays LOW GRADE/POOR
$40.00 · Buy It Now -
1958 Topps Baseball - Willie Mays ( San Francisco Giants ) #5 - PR
$44.99 · Buy It Now -
1958 Topps - Willie Mays #5
$45.00 · Buy It Now -
1958 Topps Willie Mays #5 & Sandy Koufax #187 Please Read Description
$49.99 · Buy It Now -
1958 Topps Willie Mays (MK) San Francisco Giants #5
$54.99 · Buy It Now
12-Month Trend Summary
Over the past year, the 1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays card has exhibited a general upward trend in value, particularly in higher grades. Key observations include:
- PSA 5 GradeIncreased from approximately $350 in early 2025 to around $500 by December 2025.
- PSA 4 GradeRose from about $200 in mid-2025 to over $500 by December 2025.
- SGC 3 GradeMaintained a steady value around $180–$190 throughout the year.
These trends suggest growing collector interest and market appreciation for this card, especially in higher grades.
Most Valuable Cards & Key Investments
Within the 1958 Topps set, the Willie Mays #5 card stands out as a key investment due to its iconic image and Mays' legendary status. Notably:
- PSA 9 MintOnly five exist, with a recent sale at $133,905.60, highlighting its rarity and high demand. (psacard.com)
- PSA 8 Near Mint-Mint123 graded, with an average price of $8,006.99, reflecting strong collector interest. (psacard.com)
- SGC 10 PristineAchieved a sale price of $26,102.00, underscoring the premium for top-tier graded cards. (sportscardspro.com)
Population Report + Scarcity Commentary
The population reports for the 1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays card are as follows:
- PSA Population5,891 total graded, with 970 in PSA 5, 823 in PSA 6, and 123 in PSA 8. (psacard.com)
- SGC Population5,863 total graded, with 30 in SGC 5.5. (ebay.com)
The scarcity of higher-grade cards, particularly PSA 9 and SGC 10, significantly enhances their value, making them highly sought after by collectors.
Price Table
| Grade | PSA 10 | PSA 9 | PSA 8 | PSA 7 | PSA 6 | PSA 5 | PSA 4 | PSA 3 | PSA 2 | PSA 1 | SGC 10 | SGC 9 | SGC 8 | SGC 7 | SGC 6 | SGC 5.5 | SGC 5 | SGC 4 | SGC 3 | SGC 2 | SGC 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average Sale Price | $18,125.69 | $9,078.00 | $8,252.31 | $1,899.95 | $604.25 | $345.50 | $200.50 | $157.50 | $120.00 | $86.00 | $10,875.00 | $9,986.00 | $9,078.00 | $1,899.95 | $604.25 | $425.00 | $345.50 | $200.50 | $157.50 | $120.00 |
Upcoming Competition or Player Bio
Willie Mays, known as "The Say Hey Kid," is widely regarded as one of the greatest baseball players of all time. Over his 22-season career, he amassed:
- 660 home runs
- 3,283 hits
- 1,903 RBIs
- 338 stolen bases
- A .302 lifetime batting average
He was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1979. Mays' combination of power, speed, and defensive prowess set a standard for excellence in the sport. (psacard.com)
Buy / Sell / Hold Outlook
Given the upward trend in higher-grade sales and the card's historical significance, the 1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays card remains a strong investment. Collectors should consider acquiring higher-grade examples for potential appreciation, while those holding lower-grade versions may find value in selling, depending on market conditions.