Buffalo Bills Football Card Price Guide

FOOTBALL

By Bob Villemure • Updated July 20, 2025

# Buffalo Bills Football Card Price Guide | Review & Card Values (Updated July 2025)

Franchise Overview

The Buffalo Bills, a franchise steeped in rich history and known for its passionate fan base, continue to be a significant player on the football card investment scene. Established in 1960, the Buffalo Bills have contributed greatly to the NFL’s legacy, with notable achievements and memorable moments that remain etched in the annals of football history. Their memorable four consecutive Super Bowl appearances in the early '90s, though ending in defeats, showcased a resilient and talented team. Collectors have always revered the Bills for their storied past and iconic players. From Hall of Famers like Jim Kelly, whose leadership and grit were instrumental during the team's glory days, to modern-day superstars like Josh Allen, the Bills have a compelling mix of legends and emerging talent. Cards featuring these players, particularly in pristine PSA 10 condition, are highly sought after. Rookie cards and special inserts from the Buffalo Bills hold particular allure. The 1984 Topps Jim Kelly rookie card is a perennial favorite among collectors, while the more recent Panini Prizm Josh Allen cards have seen surges in value due to Allen's on-field successes. Today, the franchise's cards are seen as both collectibles and sound investments, reflecting a blend of nostalgia and modern athletic excellence.

Quick-Stats Panel

The market for Buffalo Bills cards remains robust, with recent sales data from eBay, Goldin, and PWCC highlighting continued interest and demand. The average value for a PSA 10 Josh Allen rookie card has seen an appreciation of 15% over the past year, currently fetching prices upwards of $2,500. Grading trends show a preference for high-grade cards, with PSA and BGS dominating submissions. Wax boxes featuring key Bills players, such as the 1984 Topps Football set, remain scarce, with sealed boxes commanding premium prices. Demand is particularly high for parallels and autographs, with collectors eager to secure rare and graded examples. Recent sales comps can be explored in detail on platforms like eBay and SportscardInvestor.

Price Table

Card	PSA 10	PSA 9	PSA 1
1984 Topps Jim Kelly Rookie	$5,000	$900	$20
2018 Panini Prizm Josh Allen Rookie	$2,500	$700	$10
2020 Panini National Treasures Josh Allen Auto	$15,000	$8,000	N/A

Franchise Trend Summary

The past year has seen dynamic movement in the Buffalo Bills card market. Josh Allen's rise to prominence has been a significant factor, as his performance has drawn attention from both collectors and investors. Aided by a strong social media presence and endorsements, Allen's cards have experienced spikes in market value, influencing the overall perception of Buffalo Bills cards. Moreover, the franchise's enduring popularity, bolstered by a committed fan base and ongoing playoff appearances, has maintained a steady demand. The resurgence in vintage collecting has further fueled interest in classic cards from the franchise, such as those of Jim Kelly and Thurman Thomas.

Other Key Cards to Look For

1990 Score Thurman Thomas:

As one of the all-time greats, Thurman Thomas's rookie card is a must-have for any serious collector.

1983 Topps Bruce Smith Rookie Card:

Another Hall of Famer, Smith's rookie card is a cornerstone for Bills collectors.

2021 Panini Certified Josh Allen Mirror Gold Auto:

This limited and visually striking card is a recent hot commodity.

Population Report + Scarcity Analysis

Recent PSA population reports indicate that while there are a fair number of Jim Kelly's 1984 rookie cards graded, high-grade examples (PSA 10) remain scarce, highlighting their investment potential. In contrast, Josh Allen's cards, though newer, show a higher population of PSA 10s, reflective of modern grading and preservation methods. The scarcity of high-grade vintage Bills cards suggests strong long-term investment potential, while the emerging trends in modern cards, like those of Josh Allen, present immediate growth opportunities. Collectors should consider grading challenges when evaluating potential purchases, as well as the rarity of certain parallels and inserts.

Buy/Sell/Hold Outlook

From an investment perspective, Buffalo Bills cards offer a balanced mix of stability and growth potential. Long-term collectors are advised to

hold

high-grade vintage cards, particularly those of Jim Kelly and Thurman Thomas, due to their historical importance and limited availability. For emerging stars like Josh Allen, investors might consider

buying

key singles, especially autographed and low-numbered parallels, to capitalize on his ongoing career accomplishments. As the market continues to evolve, keeping an eye out for market dips could provide advantageous entry points for both established and new collectors. ---

# FAQs

🔥 Top 6 Auctions by Bids:

2018 Panini Unparalleled Josh Allen RC RPA Rookie Jersey Autograph
$537.99 · 29 bids · 31 minutes
Josh Allen 2025 Score Showtime SP #13 BILLS
$51.00 · 26 bids · 2 days 0 hours 37 minutes
1970 Topps #90 O.J. Simpson Buffalo Bills ROOKIE VG-VGEX (mc) NO RESERVE!
$28.00 · 17 bids · 1 hours 13 minutes
2023 Panini Contenders Dalton Kincaid Divisional Ticket RC /99 (#107)
$18.63 · 15 bids · 1 hours 22 minutes
Keon Coleman 2024 Panini Phoenix Rookie Silhouettes RPA Patch Auto RC 3/49 Bills
$34.00 · 15 bids · 58 minutes
2022 PANINI MOSAIC WHITE MOSAIC #253 JOSH ALLEN 6/25 PSA 10
$255.00 · 15 bids · 5 minutes

FAQs

Is Buffalo Bills Football Card Price Guide | FOOTBALL a good franchise to invest in long-term?

Yes, due to its historical importance and iconic rookies like Jim Kelly and emerging stars like Josh Allen.

What are the most valuable cards for the Buffalo Bills Football Card Price Guide | FOOTBALL franchise?

The 1984 Topps Jim Kelly rookie card and 2018 Panini Prizm Josh Allen rookie card are among the most valuable.

Should I grade cards from this franchise?

Only cards in strong condition with high visual appeal are worth grading—especially stars and short prints such as Josh Allen's rookie cards.

What recent trends have affected the Buffalo Bills card market?

Josh Allen's on-field performance and social media presence have increased demand and value for his cards.

Are vintage Buffalo Bills cards still worth collecting?

Yes, vintage cards from the 1980s and 1990s are highly regarded and hold significant investment potential.

Methodology & Ethics

Data sources — Goldin Auctions closing prices, eBay Terapeak analytics, and PSA Auction Prices Realized.

Sampling window — We analyse the latest 90 days of public sales. A grade appears in our tables only when at least three verified transactions exist for that grade.

AI-grading disclaimer — MarketSnap’s grade suggestions are algorithmic and should be verified by a professional grader before you buy, sell, or submit a card.

Affiliate transparency — When you click a link to an external marketplace we may earn a referral commission at no extra cost to you. These partnerships never influence a card’s ranking or our editorial commentary.

📈 Generate instant AI grade & comps