Indianapolis Colts Football Card Price Guide

FOOTBALL

By Bob Villemure • Updated July 20, 2025

Indianapolis Colts Football Card Price Guide | Review & Card Values (Updated July 2025)

---

# Franchise Overview

The Indianapolis Colts, a franchise rich with history and talent, are a cornerstone of the NFL landscape. Originally established in 1953 as the Baltimore Colts, the team moved to Indianapolis in 1984, marking a new era in the Midwest. The Colts have been home to legendary players, thrilling games, and inspiring comebacks which have cemented their status in NFL lore. The Indianapolis Colts Football Card Price Guide showcases the allure and investment potential of this storied franchise. From iconic Hall of Famers like Johnny Unitas and Peyton Manning to current stars such as Jonathan Taylor, the Colts' roster boasts some of the most collectible players in the hobby. Collectors today value the franchise for its historical significance and the potential of emerging talent. Key rookies and inserts from the Colts include sought-after cards like Peyton Manning's 1998 Topps Chrome rookie card and Marvin Harrison's 1996 Bowman’s Best rookie card. The perception of the Colts in the collecting community is one of respect for its historical players and optimism for the future, especially with new talents constantly emerging on the team.

# Quick-Stats Panel

Recent Sales Comps:

Using data from eBay, Goldin, and PWCC, Peyton Manning's 1998 Topps Chrome PSA 10 is averaging $1,200. -

Grading Trends:

Cards graded PSA 9 and above see a premium of 30-50%. Lower-grade Colts cards still hold value due to the franchise's legacy. -

Wax Box Scarcity:

1998 Topps Chrome boxes have become increasingly scarce, often breaking $4,000 in auctions. -

Demand Across Base, Parallels, and Autos:

High demand for parallels, especially refractors, and autos of iconic players like Manning and current stars like Taylor. Recent Comp Link to eBay

# Price Table

Player/Card	PSA 10 Avg. Price	PSA 9 Avg. Price	PSA 8 Avg. Price
Peyton Manning 1998 Topps Chrome	$1,200	$500	$250
Johnny Unitas 1957 Topps	$20,000	$5,000	$2,500
Reggie Wayne 2001 Topps Chrome	$150	$75	$40
Marvin Harrison 1996 Bowman’s Best	$400	$200	$100
Jonathan Taylor 2020 Prizm Silver	$250	$100	$50

# Franchise Trend Summary

Over the past year, the Indianapolis Colts card market has seen steady growth. The resurgence can be attributed to the rising performances of current players like Jonathan Taylor, sparking increased collector interest. Influencers in the hobby have highlighted the franchise's historical significance, leading to spikes in demand for vintage cards. Notably, a Johnny Unitas 1957 Topps PSA 10 recently sold for a record-breaking $300,000, underscoring the enduring appeal of Colts legends.

# Other Key Cards to Look For

Johnny Unitas 1957 Topps Rookie Card:

An iconic card representing the golden era of football, highly coveted by vintage collectors.

Peyton Manning 1998 SP Authentic Rookie Card:

Known for its scarcity and high-grade desirability.

Edgerrin James 1999 SP Authentic Rookie Card:

An essential card for those collecting Hall of Fame running backs.

T.Y. Hilton 2012 Prizm Rookie Card:

A modern classic, attractive for its design and Hilton’s significance to the franchise.

Andrew Luck 2012 Topps Chrome Refractor:

Despite his early retirement, Luck's cards remain popular among collectors.

# Population Report + Scarcity Analysis

According to PSA's population report, Peyton Manning’s 1998 Topps Chrome rookie card has over 1,500 submissions, but only 400 have achieved a PSA 10 grade, highlighting its relative scarcity. Johnny Unitas’ 1957 Topps card has fewer than 50 PSA 9s, making high-grade examples exceptionally rare and valuable. This scarcity, combined with grading difficulty for older cards, enhances long-term investment potential.

# Buy/Sell/Hold Outlook

For collectors and investors, the Indianapolis Colts offer a balanced portfolio of historical and modern assets. It's advisable to

hold

key rookies like Manning and Unitas due to their stable value and cultural significance. Consider

buying

current stars like Jonathan Taylor in the off-season for potential flips during peak performance windows.

Sell

lower-grade or overproduced cards during periods of high demand to maximize returns. ---

# User Questions and Answers

This comprehensive guide provides collectors and investors with essential insights into the Colts' card market, ensuring informed decision-making in their hobby endeavors.

🔥 Top 6 Auctions by Bids:

1998 Skybox Thunder #239 Peyton Manning Rookie BGS 9.5 True Gem
$46.00 · 23 bids · 26 minutes
2007 Upper Deck SP Chirography Peyton Manning Biography of a Star Auto /10
$110.27 · 22 bids · 42 minutes
2020 Panini Prizm #332 Jonathan Taylor RC No Huddle Prizm Rookie Auto
$26.00 · 20 bids · 15 minutes
2020 Prizm Green Disco #91 Peyton Manning Colts HOF 5/5 HGA 9.5
$51.00 · 17 bids · 1 days 21 hours 42 minutes
2023 Panini Legacy Reggie Wayne Auto Black 1/1 #142 Indianapolis Colts CC8
$43.00 · 16 bids · 23 hours 33 minutes
ANTHONY RICHARDSON 2023 CONTENDERS OPTIC #102 ROOKIE CRACKED ICE AUTO 22/22 RC
$455.00 · 15 bids · 19 minutes

FAQs

Is Indianapolis Colts Football Card Price Guide | FOOTBALL a good franchise to invest in long-term?

Yes, due to its historical importance and iconic rookies like Johnny Unitas and Peyton Manning.

What are the most valuable cards for the Indianapolis Colts Football Card Price Guide | FOOTBALL franchise?

Johnny Unitas 1957 Topps and Peyton Manning 1998 Topps Chrome lead the value charts.

Should I grade cards from this franchise?

Only cards in strong condition with high visual appeal are worth grading—especially stars and short prints such as Peyton Manning rookies.

Which modern Colts player cards are worth investing in?

Jonathan Taylor's 2020 Prizm Silver and Michael Pittman Jr.'s rookies have shown promise.

How does the market trend look for Colts cards?

The market has been growing steadily, with increased attention on vintage cards and key modern players.

Methodology & Ethics

Data sources — Goldin Auctions closing prices, eBay Terapeak analytics, and PSA Auction Prices Realized.

Sampling window — We analyse the latest 90 days of public sales. A grade appears in our tables only when at least three verified transactions exist for that grade.

AI-grading disclaimer — MarketSnap’s grade suggestions are algorithmic and should be verified by a professional grader before you buy, sell, or submit a card.

Affiliate transparency — When you click a link to an external marketplace we may earn a referral commission at no extra cost to you. These partnerships never influence a card’s ranking or our editorial commentary.

📈 Generate instant AI grade & comps